- 22 Aug, 2021 1 commit
-
-
tavit ohanian authored
-
- 16 Aug, 2021 1 commit
-
-
tavit ohanian authored
-
- 29 Jul, 2021 1 commit
-
-
tavit ohanian authored
-
- 09 Apr, 2021 2 commits
-
-
Daniel Martí authored
Now that we buffer the output, using go/format is trivial. This makes the default behavior better, and means not having to use an extra gofmt go:generate step everywhere.
-
Daniel Martí authored
And re-generate all code in this module. This gets us to a point where go-codec-dagpb has zero vet warnings, for example. schema/dmt still has a few warnings, but those are trickier to fix, so will require another PR.
-
- 07 Apr, 2021 1 commit
-
-
Daniel Martí authored
If we know that a schema type can be represented in Go with a small amount of bytes, using a pointer to store its "maybe" is rarely a good idea. For example, an optional string only weighs twice as much as a pointer, so a pointer adds overhead and will barely ever save any memory. Add a function to work out the byte size of a schema.TypeKind, relying on reflection and the basicnode package. Debug prints are also present if one wants to double-check the numbers. As of today, they are: sizeOf(small): 32 (4x pointer size) sizeOf(Bool): 1 sizeOf(Int): 8 sizeOf(Float): 8 sizeOf(String): 16 sizeOf(Bytes): 24 sizeOf(List): 24 sizeOf(Map): 32 sizeOf(Link): 16 Below is the result on go-merkledag's BenchmarkRoundtrip after re-generating go-codec-dagpb with this change. Note that the dag-pb schema contains multiple optional fields, such as strings. name old time/op new time/op delta Roundtrip-8 4.24µs ± 3% 3.78µs ± 0% -10.87% (p=0.004 n=6+5) name old alloc/op new alloc/op delta Roundtrip-8 6.38kB ± 0% 6.24kB ± 0% -2.26% (p=0.002 n=6+6) name old allocs/op new allocs/op delta Roundtrip-8 103 ± 0% 61 ± 0% -40.78% (p=0.002 n=6+6) Schema typekinds which don't directly map to basicnode prototypes, such as structs and unions, are left as a TODO for now. I did not do any measurements to arrive at the magic number of 4x, which is documented in the code. We might well increase it in the future, with more careful benchmarking. For now, it seems like a conservative starting point that should cover all basic types. Finally, re-generate within this repo.
-
- 18 Jan, 2021 1 commit
-
-
Daniel Martí authored
In particular, use keys for ipld error structs. These have one field, so the changes are pretty simple. Reduces 'go vet ./...' from 2647 lines of output to 2365. Updates #102.
-
- 10 Jan, 2021 1 commit
-
-
Daniel Martí authored
In particular, this removes ~50 out of the 2.7k warnings in 'go vet ./...' in this repository. Mainly, the "unreachable code" ones. This was caused by edge cases in some of the generated code which caused an unconditional return or panic statement to be followed by other code. Fix all of them with a bit more template logic. Some of the Next methods go a bit further. If they serve no purpose as the switch has no cases to be matched, just unconditionally return an error. In the future we can perhaps reuse a single function for that. Finally, I was having a hard time actually following the logic in kindedUnionNodeAssemblerMethodTemplateMunge, so I've indented the code a bit to follow the template logic and scoping. These changes move us towards pleasing vet, which is nice, but also make the code waste a bit less space.
-
- 31 Dec, 2020 1 commit
-
-
Eric Myhre authored
This reverts commit 6e6625bd. Discussed at https://github.com/ipld/go-ipld-prime/pull/126#issuecomment-753003441 Long story short, the motivations of this rename are good, but the new name also carries some connotations we're really not sure about, and so we're going to undo this for now, and continue to think about it in the future.
-
- 25 Dec, 2020 1 commit
-
-
Daniel Martí authored
As discussed on the issue thread, ipld.Kind and schema.TypeKind are more intuitive, closer to the spec wording, and just generally better in the long run. The changes are almost entirely automated via the commands below. Very minor changes were needed in some of the generators, and then gofmt. sed -ri 's/\<Kind\(\)/TypeKind()/g' **/*.go git checkout fluent # since it uses reflect.Value.Kind sed -ri 's/\<Kind_/TypeKind_/g' **/*.go sed -i 's/\<Kind\>/TypeKind/g' **/*.go sed -i 's/ReprKind/Kind/g' **/*.go Plus manually undoing a few renames, as per Eric's review. Fixes #94.
-
- 17 Dec, 2020 1 commit
-
-
Daniel Martí authored
This should be more intuitive to Go programmers, since assignments are generally trivial operations, but conversions imply that extra work might be needed to adapt the value to fit in the recipient. The entire change is just: sed -ri 's/AssignNode/ConvertFrom/g' **/*.go Downstream users can very likely use the same line to fix their function declarations and calls. Fixes #95.
-
- 16 Dec, 2020 1 commit
-
-
Daniel Martí authored
We only supported representing Int nodes as Go's "int" builtin type. This is fine on 64-bit, but on 32-bit, it limited those node values to just 32 bits. This is a problem in practice, because it's reasonable to want more than 32 bits for integers. Moreover, this meant that IPLD would change behavior if built for a 32-bit platform; it would not be able to decode large integers, for example, when in fact that was just a software limitation that 64-bit builds did not have. To fix this problem, consistently use int64 for AsInt and AssignInt. A lot more functions are part of this rewrite as well; mainly, those revolving around collections and iterating. Some might never need more than 32 bits in practice, but consistency and portability is preferred. Moreover, many are interfaces, and we want IPLD interfaces to be flexible, which will be important for ADLs. Below are some GNU sed lines which can be used to quickly update function signatures to use int64: sed -ri 's/(func.* AsInt.*)\<int\>/\1int64/g' **/*.go sed -ri 's/(func.* AssignInt.*)\<int\>/\1int64/g' **/*.go sed -ri 's/(func.* Length.*)\<int\>/\1int64/g' **/*.go sed -ri 's/(func.* LookupByIndex.*)\<int\>/\1int64/g' **/*.go sed -ri 's/(func.* Next.*)\<int\>/\1int64/g' **/*.go sed -ri 's/(func.* ValuePrototype.*)\<int\>/\1int64/g' **/*.go Note that the function bodies, as well as the code that calls said functions, may need to be manually updated with the integer type change. That cannot be automated, because it's possible that an automated fix would silently introduce potential overflows not being handled. Some TODOs and FIXMEs for overflow checks are removed, since we remove some now unnecessary int64->int conversions. On the other hand, the older codecs based on refmt need to gain some overflow check TODOs, since refmt uses ints. That is okay for now, since we'll phase out refmt pretty soon. While at it, update codectools to use int64 for token Length fields, so that it properly supports full IPLD integers without machine-dependent behavior and overflow checks. The budget integer is also updated to be int64, since the lengths it uses are now int64. Note that this refactor needed changes to the Go code generator as well as some of the tests, for the purpose of updating all the code. Finally, note that the code-generated iterator structs do not use int64 fields internally, even though they must return int64 numbers to implement the interface. This is because they use the numeric fields to count up to a small finite amount (such as the number of fields in a Go struct), or up to the length of a map/slice. Neither of them can ever outgrow "int". Fixes #124.
-
- 14 Dec, 2020 2 commits
-
-
Eric Myhre authored
-
Eric Myhre authored
Do regeneratation. Some diff churn: the codegen doesn't yet jive smoothly with a recent change made in service to go vet. We'll want to straighten that out soon, I guess.
-
- 04 Dec, 2020 1 commit
-
-
Daniel Martí authored
Reduces the output of 'go vet ./...' from 374 lines to 96. Many warnings remain, but I have lost my patience for today. Most of the changes below were automated, especially the single-line mixins expressions. Unfortunately, many of the Traits structs required manual copy-pasting.
-
- 01 Dec, 2020 1 commit
-
-
Daniel Martí authored
The files in this codegen demo correspond to an older version of the Go code generator. That's not terrible in itself, but it did make repeated uses of 'go test' fail: $ go test testing: warning: no tests to run PASS ok github.com/ipld/go-ipld-prime/node/gendemo 0.112s $ go test # github.com/ipld/go-ipld-prime/node/gendemo [github.com/ipld/go-ipld-prime/node/gendemo.test] ./minima.go:10:2: midvalue redeclared in this block previous declaration at ./ipldsch_minima.go:13:27 [...]
-
- 10 Sep, 2020 1 commit
-
-
Daniel Martí authored
Buffers are not a good option for tests if the other side expects a reader. Otherwise, the code being tested could build assumptions around the reader stream being a single contiguous chunk of bytes, such as: _ = r.(*bytes.Buffer).Bytes() This kind of hack might seem unlikely, but it's an easy mistake to make, especially with APIs like fmt which automatically call String methods. With bytes.Reader and strings.Reader, the types are much more restricted, so the tests need to be more faithful.
-
- 05 Sep, 2020 1 commit
-
-
Eric Myhre authored
This new system focuses on table-driven tests, and leans heavily upon json as a shorthand for expressing fixtures. It also makes a great deal more effort to exercise the different features of nodes (and their paired representation nodes) from all directions at once for each test datum, rather than requring that all be written out manually. The result is that the struct tests we've renovated have a lovely diffstat shrinkage: 111 insertions, 299 deletions... And yet the smaller line count results in *more* coverage. (Okay, the linecount increase for the testcase structure and helper methods is much bigger than the savings in fixture size... but, only *so far*. I assume this will continue to pay off in the future.) Relatedly: a bug in struct map representations has been fixed. (It was the sibling of 5f589653, embarassingly.) Thank goodness we now get proper coverage of this area. There's a few TODOs left to further expand the exercises, but those can slot in easily in subsequent commits. Same goes for further expansion of usage of this new system.
-
- 30 Jul, 2020 2 commits
-
-
Eric Myhre authored
This will become relevant when we have structs with tuple representation!
-
Eric Myhre authored
Fix a somewhat horrendous parity break in struct assembly between the AssembleEntry shortcut and AssembleKey+AssembleValue.
-
- 09 Jul, 2020 1 commit
-
-
Eric Myhre authored
This is full of mundane plonking away at adding stars and ampersands, of which approximately none are interesting. (I'm particularly frustrated by this because these are all placeholder types, and we're getting *very* close to replacing them, as we get closer and closer to self-hosting... at which point all of this bonking about will be made totally irrelevant. And yet to close the last mile, these "small" fixes are surprisingly irritating. Ah well.) The bits that *are* interesting: - the Spawn functions for type info now take strings rather than types (so that they don't provoke a cycle problem for the user when constructing the information to describe cyclic type info); - all of the Type info structure hold a pointer to the TypeSystem, and use that to look up reified Type info for related types, so that their methods don't force the caller to do that themselves. (The TypeSystem pointer was already there, amusingly; just never before initialized, because it hadn't turned out to be load-bearing yet.) It also would've been possible to just change all the methods on the Type types to return TypeName rather than full Type info. That would avoid the need to use a TypeSystem pointer. I didn't because: Overall, this was done in such a way as to minimize the diff that impacts within the templates. This was a goal because updating templates is a fair bit more work than other code due to the weak compiler support. And we'll end up reviewing and changing these methods when we get to our goal of self-hosting generation of the schema types from the schema-schema, so, it's not worth pushing around diffs in that same area when they'd be sure to be churned under soon.
-
- 29 Jun, 2020 2 commits
-
-
Eric Myhre authored
-
Eric Myhre authored
Hopefully this increases clarity and eases comprehension. Notes and discussion can be found at https://github.com/ipld/go-ipld-prime/issues/54 (and also I suppose in some of our weekly video chats, but I'd have to go on quite a dig to find the relevant links and time). Many many refernces to 'ns' are also updated to 'np', making the line count in this diff pretty wild.
-
- 26 Jun, 2020 2 commits
-
-
Eric Myhre authored
See the changelog for discussion; this had already been on the docket for a while now.
-
Eric Myhre authored
... and it will further become LookupByNode shortly, but that will be a separate commit. See the changelog for discussion; this had already been on the docket for a while now.
-
- 15 Jun, 2020 1 commit
-
-
Eric Myhre authored
(It's a small diff -- just reflecting the fix for map returing absent.)
-
- 22 May, 2020 2 commits
-
-
Eric Myhre authored
Previously, it was manually written prototypes of what gen "would" look like. Now it's the real deal :3
-
Eric Myhre authored
Some of them still lived over the "gendemo" package, and those are now moved over here to the proper gen package. Linked to more of the other documents from the main HACKME doc.
-
- 26 Mar, 2020 1 commit
-
-
Eric Myhre authored
-
- 11 Mar, 2020 1 commit
-
-
Eric Myhre authored
Saying "Node" again in the middle is just purely redundant and doesn't improve clarity in any meaningful way. Begone with it.
-
- 02 Mar, 2020 1 commit
-
-
Eric Myhre authored
This is a *lot* of changes. It's the most significant change to date, both in semantics and in character count, since the start of this repo. It changes the most central interfaces, and significantly so. But all tests pass. And all benchmarks are *improved*. The Node interface (the reading side) is mostly unchanged -- a lot of consuming code will still compile and work just fine without changes -- but any other Node implementations out there might need some updating. The NodeBuilder interface (the writing side) is *extremely* changed -- any implementations out there will *definitely* need change -- and most consumers will too. It's unavoidable with a semantic fix this big. The performance improvements should make it worth your while, though. If you want more background on how and why we got here, you've got quite a few commits on the "research-admissions" branches to catch up on reading. But here's a rundown of the changes: (Get a glass of water or something calming before reading...) === NodeAssembler introduced! === NodeAssembler is a new interface that describes most of the work of creating and filling data into a new Node. The NodeBuilder interface is still around, but changed in role. A NodeBuilder is now always also a NodeAssembler; additionally, it can return the final Node to you. A NodeAssembler, unlike NodeBuilder, can **not** return a Node to you. In this way, a NodeBuilder represents the ability to allocate memory. A NodeAssembler often *does not*: it's just *filling in* memory. This design overall is much more friendly to efficient operations: in this model, we do allocations in bulk when a NodeBuilder is used, and then NodeAssemblers are used thereafter to fill it in -- this mental model is very friendly to amortizing memory allocations. Previously, the NodeBuilder interface made such a pattern of use somewhere between difficult and outright impossible, because it was modeled around building small values, then creating a bigger value and inserting the smaller ones into it. This is the key change that cascaded into producing the entire other set of changes which land in this commit. The NodeBuilder methods for getting "child builders" are also gone as a result of these changes. The result feels a lot smoother. (You can still ask for the NodeStyle for children of a recursive kind! But you'll find that even though it's possible, it's rarely necessary.) We see some direct improvements from this interface change already. We'll see even more in the future: creating values when using codegen'd implementations of Node was hugely encumbered by the old NodeBuilder model; NodeAssembler *radically* raises the possible ceiling for performance of codegen Node implementations. === NodeStyle introduced === NodeStyle is a new interface type that is used to carry information about concrete node implementations. You can always use a NodeStyle to get a NodeBuilder. NodeStyle may also have additional features on it which can be detected by interface checks. (This isn't heavily used yet, but we imagine it might become handy in the future.) NodeStyle replaces NodeBuilder in many function arguments, because often what we wanted was to communicate a selection of Node implementation strategy, but not actually the start of construction; the NodeStyle interface now allows us to *say that*. NodeStyle typically cost nothing to pass around, whereas a NodeBuilder generally requires an allocation to create and initialize. This means we can use NodeStyle more freely in many contexts. === node package paths changed === Node implementations are now in packages under the "node/*" directory. Previously, they were under an "impl/*" directory. The "impl/free" package is replaced by the the "node/basic" package! The package name was "ipldfree"; it's now "basicnode". === basicnode is an improved runtime/anycontent Node implementation === The `basicnode` package works much the same as the `ipldfree` package used to -- you can store any kind of data in it, and it just does as best it can to represent and handle that, and it works without any kind of type info nor needs of compile-time special support, etc -- while being just quietly *better at it*. The resident memory size of most things has gone down. (We're not using "fat unions" in the implementation anymore.) The cost of iterating maps has gone down *dramatically*. Iteration previously suffered from O(n) allocations due to expensive `runtime.conv*` calls when yielding keys. Iteration is now O(1) (!!) because we redesigned `basicnode` internals to use "internal pointers" more heavily, and this avoids the costs from `runtime.conv*`. (We could've done this separately from the NodeAssembler change, admittedly. But both are the product of research into how impactful clever use of "internal pointers" can be, and lots of code in the neighborhood had to be rewritten for the NodeAssembler interface, so, these diffs arrive as one.) Error messages are more informative. Many small operations should get a few nanoseconds faster. (The implementation uses more concrete types and fewer switch statements. The difference probably isn't the most noticeable part of all these changes, but it's there.) --- basicnode constructor helpers do all return pointers --- All the "New*" helper functions in the basicnode package return interfaces which are filled by a pointer now. This is change from how they worked previously when they were first implemented in the "rsrch" package. The experience of integrating basicnode with the tests in the traversal package made it clear that having a mixture of pointer and non-pointer values flying around will be irritating in practice. And since it is the case that when returning values from inside a larger structure, we *must* end up returning a pointer, pointers are thus what we standardize on. (There was even some writeup in the HACKME file about how we *might* encounter issues on this, and need to change to pointers-everywhere -- the "pointer-vs-value inhabitant consistency" heading. Yep: we did. And since this detail is now resolved, that doc section is dropped.) This doesn't really make any difference to performance. The old way would cause an alloc in those method via 'conv*' methods; the new way just makes it more explicit and go through a different runtime method at the bottom, but it's still the same number of allocations for essentially the same reasons. (I do wonder if at some future point, the golang compiler might get cleverer about eliding 'conv*' calls, and then this change we make here might be unfortunate; but that's certainly not true today, nor in the future at any proximity that I can foresee.) === iterator getters return nil for wrong-kind === The Node.MapIterator and Node.ListIterator methods now return nil if you call them on non-maps or non-lists. Previously, they would return an iterator, but using it would just constantly error. I don't think anyone was honestly really checking those error thunks, and they made a lot of boilerplate white noise in the implementations, and the error is still entirely avoidable by checking the node kind up-front (and this is strictly preferable anyway, since it's faster than getting an error thunk, poking it to get the error, etc)... so, in total, there seem like very few reasons these were useful: the idea is thus dropped. Docs in the Node interface reflect this. === node/mixins makes new Node implementations easier === The mixins package isn't usable directly, but if you're going to make a new Node implementation, it should save you a lot of typing... and also, boost consistency of basic error handling. Codegen will look forward to using this. (Codegen already had much of these semantics internally, and so this package is sort of lifting that back out to be more generally usable. By making it live out here as exported symbols in the core library, we should also reduce the sheer character count of codegen output.) === 'typed.Node' is now 'schema.TypedNode' === A bunch of interfaces that were under the "impl/typed" path moved to be in the "schema" package instead. This probably makes sense to you if you look at them and needs no further explanation. (The reason it comes in this diff, though, is that it was forced: adding better tests to the traversal package highlighted a bunch of cyclic dependency issues that came from 'typed.Node' being in a package that had concrete use of 'basicnode'.) === codecs === The 'encoding' package is now named 'codec'. This name is shorter; it's more in line with vocabulary we use elsewhere in the IPLD project (whereas 'encoding' was more of a nod to the naming found in the golang standard library); and in my personal opinion it does better at describing the both directions of the process (whereas 'encoding' sounds like only the to-linear-bytes direction). I just like it better. === unmarshal functions no longer return node === Unmarshal functions accept an NodeAssembler parameter (rather than a NodeBuilder, as before, nor a NodeStyle, which might also make sense in the new family of interfaces). This means they no longer need to return a Node, either -- the caller can decide where the unmarshalled data lands. If the caller is using a NodeBuilder, it means they can call Build on that to get the value. (If it's a codegen NodeBuilder with More Information, the caller can use any specialized functions to get the more informative pointers without need for casting!) Broadly speaking, this means users of unmarshal functions have more control over how memory allocation comes into play. We may want to add more helper functions to the various codec packages which take a NodeStyle argument and do return a Node. That's not in this diff, though. (Need to decide what pattern of naming these various APIs would deserve, among other things.) === the fluent package === The fluent package changed significantly. The readonly/Node side of it is dropped. It didn't seem to get a ton of exercise in practice; the 'traversal' package (and in the future, perhaps also a 'cursor' package) addresses a lot of the same needs, and what remains is also covered well these days by the 'must' package; and the performance cost of fluent node wrappers as well as the composability obstruction of them... is just too much to be worth it. The few things that used fluent.Node for reading data now mostly use the 'must' package instead (and look better for it, imo). It's possible that some sort of fluent.Node will be rebuilt someday, but it's not entirely clear to me what it should look like, and indeed whether or not it's a good idea to have in the repo at all if the performance of it is counterindicated in a majority of situations... so, it's not part of today's update. The writing/NodeBuilder/NodeAssembler fluent wrappers are continued. It's similar to before (panics promptly on errors, and has a lot of closures)... but also reflects all of the changes made in the migration towards NodeAssembler: it doesn't return intermediate nodes, and there's much less kerfuffle with getting child builders. Overall, the fluent builders are now even more streamlined than before; the closures need even fewer parameters; great success! The fluent.NodeAssembler interface retains the "Create" terminology around maps and lists, even though in the core interfaces, the ipld.NodeAssembler interface now says "Begin" for maps and lists. This is because the fluent.NodeAssembler approach, with its use of closures, really does do the whole operation in one swoop. (It's amusing to note that this change includes finally nuking some fairly old "REVIEW" comment blocks from the old fluent package which regarded the "knb" value and other such sadness around typed recursion. Indeed, we've finally reviewed that: and the answer was indeed to do something drastically different to make those recursions dance well.) === selectors === Selectors essentially didn't change as part of this diff. Neat. (They should get a lot faster when applied, because our node implementations hit a lot less interface boxing in common operations! But the selector code itself didn't need to change to get the gains.) The 'selector/builder' helper package *did* change a bit. The changes are mostly invisible to the user. I do have some questions about the performance of the result; I've got a sneaking suspicion there's now a bunch of improvements that might be easier to get to now than they would've been previously. But, this is not my quest today. Perhaps it will deserve some review in the future. The 'selector/builder' package should be noted as having some interesting error handling strategies. Namely, it doesn't. Any panics raised by the fluent package will just keep rising; there's no place where they're converted to regular error value returns. I'm not sure this is a good interface, but it's the way it was before I started passing through, so that's the way it stays after this patch. ExploreFieldsSpecBuilder.Delete disappears. I hope no one misses it. I don't think anyone will. I suspect it was there only because the ipld.MapBuilder interface had such a method and it seemed like a reasonable conservative choice at the time to proxy it; now that the method proxied is gone, though, so too shall go this. === traversal === Traversal is mostly the same, but a few pieces of config have new names. `traversal.Config.LinkNodeBuilderChooser` is now `traversal.Config.LinkTargetNodeStyleChooser`. Still a mouthful; slightly more accurate; and reflects that it now works in terms of NodeStyle, which gives us a little more finesse in reasoning about where NodeBuilders are actually created, and thus better control and insight into where allocations happen. `traversal.NodeBuilderChooser` is now `traversal.LinkTargetNodeStyleChooser` for the same reasons. The actual type of the `LinkTargetNodeStyleChooser` now requires returning a `NodeStyle`, in case all the naming hasn't made it obvious. === disappearing node packages === A couple of packages under 'impl/*' are just dropped. This is no real loss. The packages dropped were Node implementations that simply weren't done. Deleting them is an increase in honesty. This doesn't mean something with the same intentions as those packages won't come back; it's just not today. --- runtime typed node wrapper disappeared --- This one will come back. It was just too much of a pain to carry along in this diff. Since it was also a fairly unfinished proof-of-concept with no downstream users, it's easier to drop and later reincarnate it than it is to carry it along now. === linking === Link.Load now takes a `NodeAssembler` parameter instead of a `NodeBuilder`, and no longer returns a `Node`! This should result in callers having a little more control over where allocations may occur, letting them potentially reuse builders, etc. This change should also make sense considering how codec.Unmarshal now similarly takes a NodeAssembler argument and does not return a Node value since its understood that the caller has some way to access or gather the effects, and it's none of our business. Something about the Link interface still feels a bit contorted. Having to give the Load method a Loader that takes half the same arguments all over again is definitely odd. And it's tempting to take a peek at fixing this, since the method is getting a signature change. It's unclear what exactly to do about this, though, and probably a consequential design decision space... so it shall not be reopened today during this other large refactor. Maybe soon. Maybe. === the dag-json codec === The dag-json codec got harder to implement. Rrgh. Since we can't tell if something is going to become a Link until *several tokens in*, dag-json is always a bit annoying to deal with. Previously, however, dag-json could still start optimistically building a map node, and then just... quietly drop it if we turn out to be dealing with a link instead. *That's no longer possible*: the process of using NodeAssembler doesn't have a general purpose mechanism for backtracking. So. Now the dag-json codec has to do even more custom work to buffer tokens until it knows what to do with them. Yey. The upside is: of course, the result is actually faster, and does fewer memory allocations, since it gathers enough information to decide what it's doing before it begins to do it. (This is a lovely example of the disciplined design of NodeAssembler's interface forcing other code to be better behaved and disciplined!) === traversal is faster === The `BenchmarkSpec_Walk_MapNStrMap3StrInt/n=32` test has about doubled in speed on the new `basicnode` implementation in comparison to the old `ipldfree.Node` implementation. This is derived primarily from the drop in costs of iteration on `basicnode` compared to the old `ipldfree.Node` implementation. Some back-of-the-envelope math on the allocation still left around suggest it could double in speed again. The next thing to target would be allocations of paths, followed by iterator allocations. Both are a tad trickier, though (see a recently merge-ignore'd commit for notes on iterators; and paths... paths will be a doozy because the path forward almost certainly involves path values becoming invalid if retained beyond a scope, which is... unsafe), so certainly need their own efforts and separate commits. === marshalling is faster === Marshalling is much faster on the new `basicnode` implementation in comparison to the old `ipldfree.Node` implementation. Same reasons as traversal. Some fixes to marshalling which previously caused unnecessary allocations of token objects during recursions have also been made. These improve speed a bit (though it's not nearly as noticeable as the boost provided by the Node implementation improvements to iteration). === size hints showed up all over the place === The appearance of size hint arguments to assembly of maps and lists is of course inevitable from the new NodeAssembler interface. It's particularly interesting to see how many of them showed up in the selector and selectorbuilder packages as constants. And super especially interesting how many of them are very small constants. 44 zeros. 86 ones. 25 twos. 9 threes. 2 fours. (Counted via variations of `grep -r 'Map(.*4, func' | wc -l`.) It's quite a distribution, neh? We should probably consider some more optimizations specifically targeted to small maps. (This is an unscientific sample, and shifted by what we chose to focus on in testing, etc etc, but the general point stands.) `-1` is used to indicate "no idea" for size. There's a small fix to the basicnode implementations to allow this. A zero would work just as well in practice, but using a negative number as a hint to the human seems potentially useful. It's a shame we can't make the argument optional; oh well. === codegen === The codegen packages still all compile... but do nonsensical things, for the moment: they've not been updated to emit NodeAssembler. Since the output of codegen still isn't well rigged to test harnesses, this breakage is silent. The codegen packages will probably undergo a fairly tabula-rasa sweep in the near future. There's been a lot of lessons learned since the start of the code currently there. Updating to emit the NodeAssembler interface will be such a large endeavor it probably represents a good point to just do a fresh pass on the whole thing all at once. -------- ... and that's all! Fun reading, eh? Please do forgive the refactors necessary for all this. Truly, the performance improvements should make it all worth your while.
-